An extra-toed cat isn't a breed but any cat born with polydactyly, a harmless genetic variation that adds toes to one or more paws. A typical cat has 18 toes, while polydactyls often have six or seven on a front paw, sometimes forming a mitten-like thumb. The trait is dominant and especially common in New England and Atlantic Canada, where ship cats were prized as mousers, a past that suits a Lake Erie port like Buffalo.
The Hemingway nickname comes from Ernest Hemingway, who was given a six-toed cat named Snow White. Most extra-toed cats in shelters are domestic shorthairs or longhairs, so personalities and coats vary as widely as in any other cat. The main care difference is nail trimming, because extra claws can curl into the paw pads.