Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls for Adoption in Buffalo, NY

Your guide to finding and caring for an Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyl in Buffalo

Extra-toed cats suit Buffalo's older two-family homes, especially in a neighborhood like Riverside. Polydactyl is a trait, not a breed, so these cats come in every coat and personality, though the big mitten paws are what people notice first. In a Riverside upper flat, a window perch and a tall scratching post go a long way, and with snow on the ground from Christmas into early March, daily indoor play becomes a habit. Expect to trim those extra claws regularly.

198 Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls available in Buffalo and nationwide

Adopt a Polydactyl cat today

While we don't have enough cats near Buffalo, keep in mind that many rescues may offer transport.

Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls Available for Adoption Near Buffalo

About the Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyl breed

An extra-toed cat isn't a breed but any cat born with polydactyly, a harmless genetic variation that adds toes to one or more paws. A typical cat has 18 toes, while polydactyls often have six or seven on a front paw, sometimes forming a mitten-like thumb. The trait is dominant and especially common in New England and Atlantic Canada, where ship cats were prized as mousers, a past that suits a Lake Erie port like Buffalo.

The Hemingway nickname comes from Ernest Hemingway, who was given a six-toed cat named Snow White. Most extra-toed cats in shelters are domestic shorthairs or longhairs, so personalities and coats vary as widely as in any other cat. The main care difference is nail trimming, because extra claws can curl into the paw pads.

Weight
6–15 lbs
Height
8–10 in
Lifespan
12–18 yrs
Temperament
Adaptable, Curious, Affectionate
Shedding
Moderate

Owning an Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyl in Buffalo

Having an Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyl in Buffalo

Extra toes make for charming, oversized paws, but they don't decide personality or health. What matters most is each cat's age, coat and background, plus a little extra attention to claws. In Buffalo, that also means a cozy, active indoor routine for the long winter.

Temperament

Extra-toed cats range from bold, chatty companions to shy cats who warm up slowly, just like other domestic cats. Toes don't predict friendliness. In a Buffalo home where winters keep everyone indoors, a sociable cat settles in easily, while a shy cat may want a quiet room and some patience at first.

Exercise Needs

Daily interactive play with wand toys, balls and puzzle feeders keeps these cats fit, and many love to climb. Buffalo winters keep cats inside for months, so plan two short play sessions a day and put a cat tree by a window. Kittens and young adults usually want more play than seniors.

Health Considerations

The common form of polydactyly usually causes no health problems, but extra claws may not wear down and can grow into the paw pads, so check and trim them every few weeks. A rare limb condition is sometimes mistaken for it, and a veterinarian can tell them apart. Dental disease, obesity and kidney disease are typical feline concerns. New York requires rabies vaccination for cats.

Living Space

Extra-toed cats do well in apartments or houses. In Buffalo's upper flats and older two-family homes, give them vertical space, sturdy scratching posts, hiding spots and clean litter boxes. Keep window screens secure to prevent falls, and keep the cat indoors or in a secure enclosure, since coyotes are known to prey on cats.

What it costs to own an Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyl in Buffalo

ExpenseTypical costPer year
Food$25 to $50 per month$300 to $600
Pet insurance$20 to $45 per month$240 to $540
Routine vet care$150 to $350 per year$150 to $350
Other*$450 to $1,150 per year$450 to $1,150
Estimated yearly total (after year one)$1,140 to $2,640

Other costs are estimates and vary with size, age and health.

* Litter, flea prevention, a yearly dental cleaning allowance, toys and scratching posts, and home grooming and claw trims.

Adopt an Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyl in Buffalo.

Now that you know more, let’s find you a new best friend. These rescues and shelters below currently have Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls available.

Rescues in Buffalo with Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls Available

Buffalo's shelters and rescues care for cats of every age and coat, and the ones serving the area are listed below. Here are the rescues & shelters in the Buffalo area where you can find Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls and other cats available for adoption.

Frequently Asked Questions

Yes, you can get an Extra-Toes Cat in Buffalo, and extra toes aren't regulated. New York doesn't license cats, but cats must be vaccinated against rabies by four months old, with a second shot within a year and boosters after. Keep vaccination records handy for landlords and veterinarians.

Yes, an Extra-Toes Cat can live happily in a Buffalo apartment, since these cats adapt to apartments like any domestic cat. Provide a window perch, a tall cat tree, sturdy scratching posts and daily play, and secure the window screens in upper-floor units. Read the lease for pet clauses before you sign.

Yes, indoor Extra-Toes Cats handle Buffalo winters well, since extra toes aren't known to affect cold tolerance. About 95 inches of snow falls each year, and some storms bring multi-day driving bans, so keep the cat inside, stock several days of food, litter and medication, and offer a warm bed away from drafts.

An Extra-Toes Cat is a good fit for Buffalo if you can offer indoor play and company through the long winter. Extra toes don't set personality, so a lively cat will want daily wand-toy sessions, while a shy one may prefer a calm home. Plan on regular claw checks and a cozy window spot for snowy days.

Most Extra-Toes Cats need a brush once or twice a week, more for longhaired coats, since shedding is moderate and varies by cat. Check and trim claws every few weeks, because extra claws can curl into the paw pads. Home grooming keeps costs low and falls within the Other line of $450–$1,150 a year, alongside litter and dental care.

No, Extra-Toes Cats can't ride public transit in Buffalo. NFTA Metro allows only service animals on its buses and Metro Rail, with no carrier exception for pets. Plan vet visits and moving days by car, and keep your cat in a secure carrier for the trip.

No, Buffalo restaurants aren't set up to welcome cats. New York's outdoor-dining rule lets owners admit pet dogs to patios, but it doesn't extend to cats. Patio season is short anyway, so your cat is usually happier at home with a window perch than on a busy Elmwood Avenue sidewalk.

A cat normally has 18 toes: five on each front paw and four on each back paw. The fifth front toe is the dewclaw, set higher on the inside of the leg like a thumb, so it doesn't touch the ground when the cat walks. Polydactyl cats have more than 18, most often an extra one or two per front paw.

We have 1 rescue with Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls available: West Side Cat Sanctuary. You can see every rescue with Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls available in the list above these questions, or scroll to the top to see the Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls near Buffalo.

Plan on roughly $25–$50 a month for food, $20–$45 a month for pet insurance, $150–$350 a year for routine vet care, and $450–$1,150 a year for other costs such as litter, flea prevention and dental care. That adds up to about $1,140–$2,640 a year, before any emergency or illness care.

Find Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls in Nearby Cities

Expand your search to find Extra-Toes Cat / Hemingway Polydactyls available for adoption near Buffalo.